Hinshaw Defends Insurance Company in Precedent-Setting Insurance Coverage Case

September 26, 2011

Sina Bahadoran and Eric A. Hiller, attorneys in the Miami office of Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP, defended an insurance company in a precedent-setting declaratory judgment action. Defendant had issued an individual umbrella policy with limits of $1 million, and plaintiff had issued a group personal umbrella with limits of $5 million. Arguing that its policy was “super excess” and so was not triggered until defendant’s policy was exhausted, plaintiff relied on several New York decisions allowing “super excess” clauses. Defendant’s policy was controlled by Florida law, which was essentially silent on the issue.

As a matter of first impression under Florida law, the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Florida granted defendant’s motion for summary judgment. The court ruled that: (1) Florida does not recognize “super excess” clauses but rather reverts to the mutual repugnancy rule, and (2) New York law may allow “super excess,” but it can yield to the ratable contribution rule depending upon the circumstances.

Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP is a U.S. based law firm with offices in 11 states and London. The firm's national reputation spans the insurance industry, the professional services sector—including representation of law firms and lawyers—and other highly regulated industries, such as banking and finance and the debt collection sector. Hinshaw also provides a series of closely coordinated litigation, business advisory and transactional services to clients of all sizes as well as governmental and public sector entities.