Expert Demonstrations Must Meet Substantially Similar Standard
Healthcare Alert | 2 min read
Dec 17, 2020
Issues
Must an expert's demonstration be made under substantially similar conditions and circumstances as those which surrounded the occurrence? Can an expert opine regarding the permanency of injuries without recent medical data?
Case Summary
A gastroenterologist lacerated plaintiff's esophagus while performing an endoscopy to remove a 2.5cm dental appliance with a "long and tortuous wire," described as "almost like a fishhook," she had swallowed while kissing her boyfriend. Plaintiff's expert maintained that defendant should have used an "overtube" to protect against injury during the EGD removal. At trial, the jury returned a verdict for defendants. Plaintiff appealed, in part, due to the trial court's refusal to allow her expert to demonstrate how use of an overtube could have avoided the laceration, and to testify that her resulting pain and constipation were permanent.
The appellate court found that plaintiff's expert's proposed demonstration of how the overtube could be slipped over an exemplar of the dental appliance by hand was not substantially similar to that undertaken by defendant, which involved the use of an endoscope. Because the proposed demonstration involved the use of manual force to draw the appliance within the overtube, the demonstration appeared deceptively easy. In addition, the proposed demonstration involved a dental appliance being drawn into the overtube while lying flat on a table, as opposed to within a patient's esophagus with limited visibility. The court concluded that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in refusing to allow such demonstration.
The appellate court also determined that the trial court did not abuse its discretion in prohibiting plaintiff's expert from opining about the permanency of plaintiff's injuries. None of the depositions or medical records established that plaintiff's injuries were permanent. Plaintiff's expert never examined plaintiff, viewed her surgical scar, or consulted with her treating physicians. In fact, no treating physician had examined the patient in the two years before trial, which resulted in a paucity of medical data from which plaintiff's expert, or any physician, could reasonably rely upon to opine regarding the permanency of her pain and/or constipation.
Takeaway
Expert demonstrations must meet the "substantially similar" standard and the absence of testimony, recent medical records, or other medical data can undermine opinions regarding the permanency of injuries.
>> Return to Hinshaw's Annual Guide to Illinois Medical Malpractice Decisions: 2020 Edition
Related Capabilities
Featured Insights
![[Byline] Revisiting Disparate Impact Liability Under Executive Order 14281](/a/web/9w8wghM45uReApTZbaaDqe/eFisyR/examining-disparate-impact-liability-in-financial-services-under-executive-order-14281-insights.jpg)
In The News
Nov 18, 2026
[Byline] Revisiting Disparate Impact Liability Under Executive Order 14281

In The News
Nov 17, 2026
Justin Penn Examines FCRA Trends Involving “Legal vs. Factual Inaccuracy” Defense

Consumer Crossroads: Where Financial Services and Litigation Intersect
Nov 16, 2026
SCOTUS to Decide: Are Bankruptcy Stay Violations Arbitrable?

Press Release
Nov 13, 2026
Hinshaw Advises Client Safe Harbor Capital Partners in $44 Million Financing

In The News
Nov 12, 2026
Spencer Kook Authors Article Providing a Claims Manager’s Guide to Class Action Exposure

In The News
Nov 12, 2026
Mitch Chargo Discusses Cannabis M&A Implications in a Post-Rescheduling Landscape

Webinar
Nov 12, 2026
Michael Adams Presents on Navigating Ethics in the Digital Age

Event
Nov 12, 2026
Cathy Mulrow-Peattie Discusses AI and Supply Chain Cybersecurity

Healthcare Alert
Nov 11, 2026
Illinois Enacts 340B Contract Pharmacy Protections: 7 Steps Covered Entities Should Take

In The News
Nov 10, 2026
Brian Turetsky Examines How NYC’s Proposed POWER Act Could Expand Private UDAAP Claims

In The News
Nov 9, 2026
Kate Schnake Examines Unlawful Discrimination vs. Legitimate Advocacy in Jury Selection

