Factors Relevant to Resolution of Multiple Claims in Excess of Limits
Insurance Coverage Alert
Insights for Insurers Alert | 3 min read
Dec 7, 2010
In Vallev. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 2010 WL 3310616 (11th Cir. Fla. 2010), an insurer was confronted with eight claims from an auto accident, including a fatality, with policy limits of only $10,000 per person/$20,000 per accident. About one month after the accident, the insurer invited all interested parties to a settlement conference. After receiving responses from all interested parties except for the decedent’s representatives, the insurer offered to pay the policy limits towards a settlement if all parties consented to an allocation between them. The decedent’s representative did not make a settlement demand before the conference, and the insurer did not make a specific offer to the decedent’s representatives.
At the settlement conference, which was held 2.5 months after the initial invitation, the parties (except for the decedent’s representatives) agreed that the insurer should pay the per person limit of $10,000 to the estate, and split the remaining $10,000 among the seven other claimants. During the settlement conference, the decedent’s representative learned that the other parties had actually agreed prior to the conference to split the $10,000. The lawyer for the decedent’s representative refused to accept the proposed settlement and sued the insurer for delay in failing to settle her claim sooner. She also sued the insured and recovered a $4 million judgment and an assignment of the insured’s bad faith claim against the insurer.
The primary argument for bad faith was that, under Florida law, an insurer’s delay in settling claims where liability is clear and the damages are in excess of the policy limits constitutes bad faith. Powell v. Prudential Property & Cas. Ins. Co., 584 So. 2d 12, 14 (Fla. Dist. Ct. App. 1991). But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit noted that an insurer will only have committed bad faith if its delay was willful and unreasonable and the carrier knowingly increased the risk of the insured’s exposure to excess liability. Valle v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 2010 WL 3310616 (11th Cir. Fla. 2010). The burden of proof is on the claimant/insured.
Although the insured was exposed to a $4 million judgment, there was no evidence that the insurer knew or should have known that its prompt effort to reach an agreement as to a distribution of the proceeds, and its willingness to pay its entire policy limits, would subject the insured to an excess judgment. Key factors included the absence of a formal demand from the decedent’s representative, and the fact that there was no indication that she would refuse the policy limits settlement and make a post hoc claim that the offer was untimely.
Practice Note
This case may give comfort to carriers that take prompt and affirmative steps to negotiate a settlement where the claims exceed the limits, but it should be noted that the matter involved unique circumstances. First, the carrier immediately attempted to pay its limits in a settlement to all claimants. Second, the claimant’s conduct did not indicate any urgency to settling the matter, and gave no indication that she would sue the insured if she did not immediately get the bulk of the policy limits. In hindsight, where one of many claims is significantly larger than the others, as in this case, it is generally prudent to make the per person limit tender to that claimant sooner than the 3.5 months after the accident.
This alert has been prepared by Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP to provide information on recent legal developments of interest to our readers. It is not intended to provide legal advice for a specific situation or to create an attorney-client relationship.
Related Capabilities
Featured Insights

Lawyers' Lawyer Newsletter
Nov 19, 2026
Private Capital and Professional Independence: MSOs and the Changing Business of Law

In The News
Nov 18, 2026
William Schubert: Why Client Confidentiality Reigns Supreme for Motions to Withdraw
![[Byline] Revisiting Disparate Impact Liability Under Executive Order 14281](/a/web/9w8wghM45uReApTZbaaDqe/eFisyR/examining-disparate-impact-liability-in-financial-services-under-executive-order-14281-insights.jpg)
In The News
Nov 18, 2026
[Byline] Revisiting Disparate Impact Liability Under Executive Order 14281

In The News
Nov 17, 2026
Justin Penn Examines FCRA Trends Involving “Legal vs. Factual Inaccuracy” Defense

Consumer Crossroads: Where Financial Services and Litigation Intersect
Nov 16, 2026
SCOTUS to Decide: Are Bankruptcy Stay Violations Arbitrable?

Press Release
Nov 13, 2026
Hinshaw Advises Client Safe Harbor Capital Partners in $44 Million Financing

In The News
Nov 12, 2026
Spencer Kook Authors Article Providing a Claims Manager’s Guide to Class Action Exposure

In The News
Nov 12, 2026
Mitch Chargo Discusses Cannabis M&A Implications in a Post-Rescheduling Landscape

Webinar
Nov 12, 2026
Michael Adams Presents on Navigating Ethics in the Digital Age

Event
Nov 12, 2026
Cathy Mulrow-Peattie Discusses AI and Supply Chain Cybersecurity

Healthcare Alert
Nov 11, 2026
Illinois Enacts 340B Contract Pharmacy Protections: 7 Steps Covered Entities Should Take

