Seventh Circuit Emphasizes "Flexible" Similarly-Situated test in Discrimination Case Involving Threats, Violence at USPS
2 min read
Jan 13, 2012
A female African-American Postal Service employee of 35 years voluntarily entered a psychiatric clinic to be treated for depression, anxiety, and insomnia. While in treatment, she admitted having homicidal thoughts toward her supervisor. She was eventually discharged after much improvement and returned to work, but her supervisor learned of the threats after calling the clinic. She was almost immediately terminated for what the employer said was a violation of its workplace anti-violence policy.
The employee sued the Postal Service, alleging that she had actually been terminated based upon her race and sex in violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended. As part of her case, she showed that, shortly before her threats became known, two white male workers who had “jokingly” held down a black worker and pulled a knife on him had only been suspended for 7 days. She argued that this was evidence that the anti-violence policy was a pretext for the actual discriminatory reasons for her termination. The district court granted summary judgment for the Postal Service, reasoning that the male workers, who worked in different positions than the employee and committed a different violation, had not been “similarly situated” to the employee and so could not be used to prove her case.
On appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit reversed. The Seventh Circuit held that the district court’s analysis of the “similarly situated” question had been far too demanding. Because the male workers had been terminated by the same decisionmaker, were subject to the same anti-violence policy, and had committed a violation of at least equivalent — and possibly greater — seriousness, they were sufficiently “similarly situated,” and could be used to show that the employer had terminated the female employee for discriminatory reasons rather than violation of the anti-violence policy. The Seventh Circuit emphasized that it is concerned about “the tendency of judges in employment discrimination cases to require closer and closer comparability between the plaintiff and members of the comparison group,” because “[d]emanding nearly identical comparators can transform this evidentiary ‘boost’ into an insurmountable hurdle.”
In light of the Seventh Circuit's statements regarding the flexibility of the "similarly situated" test, employers should ensure that all disciplinary policies are evenly enforced among all employees. Any discrepancy in enforcement can later be used as comparative evidence to support a discrimination claim.
Topics
Featured Insights

In The News
Nov 18, 2026
William Schubert: Why Client Confidentiality Reigns Supreme for Motions to Withdraw
![[Byline] Revisiting Disparate Impact Liability Under Executive Order 14281](/a/web/9w8wghM45uReApTZbaaDqe/eFisyR/examining-disparate-impact-liability-in-financial-services-under-executive-order-14281-insights.jpg)
In The News
Nov 18, 2026
[Byline] Revisiting Disparate Impact Liability Under Executive Order 14281

In The News
Nov 17, 2026
Justin Penn Examines FCRA Trends Involving “Legal vs. Factual Inaccuracy” Defense

Consumer Crossroads: Where Financial Services and Litigation Intersect
Nov 16, 2026
SCOTUS to Decide: Are Bankruptcy Stay Violations Arbitrable?

Press Release
Nov 13, 2026
Hinshaw Advises Client Safe Harbor Capital Partners in $44 Million Financing

In The News
Nov 12, 2026
Spencer Kook Authors Article Providing a Claims Manager’s Guide to Class Action Exposure

In The News
Nov 12, 2026
Mitch Chargo Discusses Cannabis M&A Implications in a Post-Rescheduling Landscape

Webinar
Nov 12, 2026
Michael Adams Presents on Navigating Ethics in the Digital Age

Event
Nov 12, 2026
Cathy Mulrow-Peattie Discusses AI and Supply Chain Cybersecurity

Healthcare Alert
Nov 11, 2026
Illinois Enacts 340B Contract Pharmacy Protections: 7 Steps Covered Entities Should Take

In The News
Nov 10, 2026
Brian Turetsky Examines How NYC’s Proposed POWER Act Could Expand Private UDAAP Claims

